Monday, September 10, 2012

For Class on 9/11

Folks: Tom sent me the following for you:


Could you just let the class know that I want to make the conversation tomorrow about treating terrorists as criminals or enemy combatants?  I want to gear the class more towards this recent political discussion and debate -- i.e., Rahm Emanuel versus Eric Holder.  I suppose I want to focus them on whether this is a war in which we are engaged or rather it is a large criminal conspiracy of non-state actors?  Or, is it somewhere in between -- like, criminal plus?  And, can the U.S. pick and choose when to charge them in a military tribunal or in a federal court?  What are the positives and negatives with each view?  What is the political component to this?  Should that matter at all?  I would again direct everyone to try and watch the 90-minute "Intelligence Squared Debate" from 2010.  Thanks.